One last breath bcadf-5 Read online

  ‘Yes, I know.’

  The old man peered at him. ‘Yes, I suppose you would. But there, you see - you’ve learned to keep things to yourself in your job, haven’t you? You wouldn’t have let on that you knew that, if I hadn’t volunteered it.’

  ‘Did you ever meet Mansell Quinn, Mr Thorpe?’

  ‘Yes, once or twice. Before he went to prison.’

  ‘He’s out now.’

  ‘Yes, you said.’

  ‘Your son and Quinn stayed friends while he was in prison, didn’t they?’

  Mr Thorpe moved his jaws thoughtfully - not chewing on anything in particular, except his own saliva. He ought to have produced some cud to munch on.

  ‘Maybe.’

  ‘Yet Mansell Quinn claimed your son as an alibi for the time that Carol Proctor was killed, and William gave a different statement.’

  273

  ‘I suppose he was just telling the truth,’ said Thorpe.

  ‘But Quinn might not have seen it like that. It would have seemed like a betrayal to him.’

  ‘I can’t help that. It happens.’

  Cooper took a drink of his tea. There was no point in trying to rush somebody like Jim Thorpe. He watched the old man gazing out of the window, past the greying net curtains towards Mam Tor. Cooper waited. Mr Thorpe’s expression didn’t change, but his hand grew still, and he stopped stroking the cat. The animal looked up and met Cooper’s eye. He felt as though some communication had passed across the room at last - as if the cat, at least, understood something of the old man’s relationship with his son.

  ‘Are you going to be speaking to Will again?’ said Mr Thorpe.

  ‘Yes, I’m sure I will be.’

  ‘Tell him, then.’

  ‘Tell him what, sir?’

  The old man swallowed convulsively, as though trying to shift something that had got stuck in his throat.

  ‘Tell him if he really wants to … he can come back here.’

  274

  26

  Castleton was one of the cleanest places Ben Cooper knew. The thousands of plastic bottles, aluminium drinks cans and polystyrene cups were actually in the litter bins rather than scattered on the grass or floating in the stream. Even the feral pigeons were more attractive than the dirty grey things on city streets. When he paused near the bridge at Stones Bottom, they flocked around his feet in seconds. Even though it was already dusk, they hadn’t given up hope of a tourist with spare bread from his sandwiches to feed them.

  Cooper could still taste the dust from the cement works in the back of his throat. It made him unnaturally thirsty, and he’d have preferred to be heading for the Hanging Gate right now for a few pints of beer to wash the coating away. But he didn’t have time, if he was going to call on Alistair Page tonight. He knew Diane Fry would have said he’d spent too long at Rakelow House. But she’d wanted background on Will Thorpe, and he’d come away with plenty of that. She might see a reconciliation with his father as exactly what she needed to make Thorpe open up.

  Knowing there wasn’t time for a proper meal either, Cooper called into a chippy on the hill near the Market Place and

  275

  bought a jumbo sausage and chips, which he ate in his car. When he’d finished, he jammed the paper and wooden fork into a bin near the visitor centre, and went into one of the toilet blocks to wash the grease off his hands.

  Returning to Castleton had reminded him of the two men he’d seen from the castle on Tuesday, when he’d been with Amy and Josie. Watching the tape from the outdoor shop, he’d been convinced that he recognized Mansell Quinn as one of the men who’d been talking in that secluded spot above Cavedale. But a few hours later, the memory was fading and he was less sure. No doubt it had been his imagination leaping into action because of the similarity between the black, slicker-type waterproofs.

  Cooper was glad he’d said nothing - it would only have made him look a fool. He supposed it was the idea of Quinn in such close proximity to Amy and Josie that had frightened him beyond rationality.

  Turning his hands in the stream of warm air from a drier, he wondered when these toilets were cleaned. Early in the morning perhaps, before the first visitors. Like the bins outside, the one in the toilet block was full. And there was something scattered on the floor near his feet, and on the edge of the washbasin, speckling the stainless steel.

  Cooper looked more closely. The specks resembled the seeds that had fallen from the lime tree in Rebecca Lowe’s garden at Parson’s Croft. Under the waste pipe leading down from the washbasin, he saw a pale leaf lying in a small pool of water, as if it had dropped from someone’s clothes.

  He felt a prickling in the small of his back, and turned sharply to look at the cubicles. Only one door was closed, down at the far end.

  ‘Paranoid,’ he said to himself. ‘Paranoid - that’s what you are.’

  But still he pushed the door open, just in case. The cubicle was empty.

  276

  Then Cooper looked at the floor. He crouched, felt in his pocket for some latex gloves or a plastic bag, but found nothing because he’d left his jacket in the car. He pulled a few sheets of toilet paper off the roll. It would have to do for now.

  Gingerly, he grasped the thing in a fold of paper and held it up to the light. It was the ripe seedhcad of a grass stalk, and it had been chewed. And surely by something bigger than a mouse.

  The outer door of the toilet block creaked open on its spring. Still crouching, Cooper turned his head. An old man had entered and was unzipping himself at the urinal. He looked at Cooper squatting on the floor of the cubicle, clutching a small brown thing in a wad of toilet paper.

  ‘Pervert,’ he said. ‘You ought to get out of here before I have the police on you.’

  Alistair Page lived in a narrow lane that rose steeply from the cavern approach. The house had recently been renovated, but alterations to the appearance of a property were strictly controlled in this area. The stonework had been cleaned, the new window frames were made of pine, and the front door was a stable-type design to match the nearby cottages. In the hillside above was a house with an arched window, like a chapel.

  Page’s house sat right into the limestone cliff, with a gap knocked out of the rock big enough to take a small car. A blue Volkswagen was parked there now, but it was a narrow fit - its wing mirror came with an inch or two of a High Peak Council wheelie bin standing against the side door of the house. There was no garden. And the front door, like most of the others, opened directly on to the street.

  The view was impressive, though. The first-floor windows looked down on to the cottages in the gorge below, and right into the mouth of Peak Cavern itself.

  277

  The sight of the cavern made Ben Cooper pause. The Devil’s Arse, they called it. But surely they had the wrong part of the anatomy. To Cooper, the cavern entrance resembled a gaping maw waiting to suck in unwary passers-by, like the business end of a primeval sea creature lying just below the surface, its mouth hung with enticing stalactites and curtains of flowstone to tempt in the curious minnows that it fed on.

  And during the daytime, minnows flocked into the mouth in large numbers. Cooper had seen them queuing at the turnstile to pay their money, and gathering at the top of the ropemakers’ terraces to watch the demonstrations before venturing deeper into the cave. More of them had been climbing the path into the gorge - scores of them thronging the riverside walk to the car park. The cavern’s gaping mouth never went hungry. Not during the tourist season, anyway.

  ‘Come in, come in,’ said Alistair Page, appearing at the front door of his cottage in a black T-shirt and jeans. The was watching out for you. I don’t normally use this door much - I go in and out at the side entrance, so I’m not stepping right into the roadway.’

  ‘Of course.’

  ‘You look hot. You’ll find it cooler in here.’

  Cooper did feel a bit sticky from the walk. It wasn’t the heat that was the problem - the temperatures hadn’t g
ot anywhere near last year’s record high. It was the humidity that wore him down and made him uncomfortable.

  ‘Sit down,’ said Page. ‘Drink?’

  ‘Yes. Something cold would be good.’

  ‘Cranberry juice OK?’

  ‘Fine.’

  ‘Sit down, then, while I get the drinks.’

  Cooper didn’t like to sit down right away, if he could avoid it. Not in a house he’d never visited before. Slumped in one of these low-level imitation leather armchairs, he would miss

  278

  a lot of the details that gave a house its character and told him so much about its owner.

  So instead of accepting Page’s invitation, he paced the room a little, then stood in front of the gas fire like a man warming himself at an open hearth. Within those few seconds, he’d taken in the main impressions. There was no sign of a pet of any kind. No children, either. No sign of a partner, in fact. This was a single man’s home.

  Page’s interests were indicated by the caving and hill walking books that filled the pine shelves in an alcove next to the fireplace, and by the widescreen TV and DVD player with a neatly ordered selection of DVDs, all in their cases and possibly even arranged in alphabetical order. Cooper saw Blade Runner - Director’s Cut near one end, and The Sixth Sense at the other. Science fiction classics and disaster movies, with a smattering of comedies.

  And there were stacks of CDs, too - U2, Del Amitri, INXS. You could almost rely on being able to judge someone’s age from their CD collection. Many people formed their musical tastes in their teenage years. In Alistair’s case, the crucial period had been the late eighties and early nineties. Cooper remembered that time himself - in fact, Del Amitri’s ‘Nothing Ever Happens’ had provided the backing track for a particularly painful spell of teenage angst.

  He examined the rest of the room. During renovations to the cottage, an open-plan staircase had been installed. A couple of steps led up into a kitchen extension at the back of the house, where Page was chinking glasses and slamming the door of a fridge. Space must have been very tight, because the back window of the extension looked directly on to a stone wall bordering the next property. The whole place was very small, of course - there wouldn’t have been scope to build any bigger in this side of the gorge.

  ‘The houses at this end of town were built pretty randomly,’ said Page, coming out of the kitchen and catching Cooper’s

  279

  glance at the back window. ‘They were miners’ cottages, of course. When a new miner arrived, they used to buy a corner of someone else’s yard and put up their own property, which is why the cottages ended up so close together.’

  ‘I suppose you get the problem of tourists gawping through the windows,’ said Cooper.

  ‘Well, it’s an occupational hazard if you live in Castlcton. Aren’t you going to take a pew?’

  ‘Thanks.’

  ‘You said on the phone you were interested in a book,’ said Page.

  ‘That’s right. It’s called Death Underground.”

  ‘Yes, I’ve got a copy you can borrow. But what’s your interest? Were you really so scared by your experience on Monday?’

  ‘Well, it was pretty scary. But I remembered you mentioning a death in the cavern. A real death. It was unique, but a long time ago, you said.’

  ‘Not many people know that story now,’ said Page. He went to the shelves and pulled out a book. ‘Death Underground has a chapter on it. There was a young caver who died.’

  ‘Where did it happen?’

  ‘Some way into the system from the show cave. A place called Moss Chamber.’

  ‘That’s an odd name. How could there be moss, when there’s no light down there?’

  ‘The chamber is named after the caver. He was called Neil Moss.’

  ‘I see.’

  ‘This was back in the late fifties, when the system was first explored to any extent.’

  ‘Neil Moss was the first to discover this chamber, I suppose, if it was named after him?’

  ‘No, he didn’t discover the chamber itself, but a tiny fissure

  280

  that goes down inside the wall. You can’t see it now - only a sort of depression filled with small stones.’

  ‘Who was this man?’

  ‘Neil Moss? He was a philosophy student at Oxford University; about twenty years old at the time. In March 1959 he joined a party exploring beyond the Mucky Ducks. When they saw the opening in the rock, Moss volunteered to try it out, to see how far it went. The thing about this shaft is that it’s only about two feet wide. A human body barely fits into it, and it must have been a really tight squeeze for Moss. It also descends at a steep angle, and about eighteen feet down there’s a corkscrew twist which he just managed to get round. Moss reached the bottom. But on the way back up, he got stuck.’

  ‘Damn.’

  ‘The shaft was so narrow that he couldn’t bend his legs or move his arms. He couldn’t do anything to raise himself. Unfortunately, he wasn’t belayed - they’d assumed that the shaft was too tight for him to fall through it. It was only when he got stuck that a line was lowered. But it was a light hand-line, not meant for hauling the weight of a human body. They struggled for nearly three days, trying to get Neil Moss out.’

  ‘Three days?’

  ‘If he’d been able to move just a few inches, it would have made all the difference,’ said Page. ‘But carbon dioxide sinks. And at the level where Neil Moss was trapped, it began to build up, fouling his air. On top of that, his acetylene lamp went out, adding carbide fumes to the mix. Cave rescue techniques weren’t as good then as they are now. The party had no oxygen with them - you know lack of oxygen causes brain damage?’

  ‘Of course.’

  ‘Well, Moss became weaker and weaker, until he was unconscious. Eventually, his father sent a message that he didn’t want any more people risking their lives trying to save

  281

  his son. So Neil Moss died down there. He was unable to move or, finally, to breathe.’

  Cooper was hardly aware of his surroundings now. Mentally, he’d put himself in the young caver’s place and was trapped in a two-foot cleft in the rock, unable to move his arms and legs, with his air almost exhausted.

  ‘You can take the book with you, if you want,’ said Page.

  ‘Thanks.’

  ‘It wasn’t the best of times for the cave rescue organizations. They took a lot of flak over that lad’s death, and it put exploration back for years.’

  Cooper picked up the book. It was the sort of thing you’d only find in a secondhand bookshop or a library. Mansell Quinn had found one in the prison library at Sudbury, perhaps donated by some benefactor. What had been his fascination with it?

  ‘Can you explain how far into the cavern it was that Moss died, Alistair?’

  ‘I can do better than that - I can show you.’

  Page unfolded a huge map of the Peak-Speedwell cave system and spread it out on the floor, which was the only flat surface big enough. He crouched over it eagerly, like a child showing off a favourite game.

  This shows the whole system, as far as we know. It links up Peak and Speedwell caverns, as you can see.’

  ‘It’s vast,’ said Cooper. ‘Is it possible to get all the way through from one show cave to the other?’

  Page poked a finger at a point in the middle of the map. ‘Well, for a long time a boulder choke at the end of the Trenches here was the limit from Peak Cavern. But in the eighties some cavers managed to force a way through into a low passage they called Colostomy Crawl. That was the first time non-divers could get into Speedwell.’

  Cooper looked for the Peak Cavern entrance. ‘Visitors only see a very small part of it on the show cave tour, don’t they?’

  282

  ‘Only as far as the top of the Devil’s Staircase these days. They used to be taken through Five Arches, but the passage floods completely in wet weather and it gets too muddy. On the exercise, we took you past th
at. And the party Neil Moss was with went way beyond Five Arches.’

  Page continued to move his finger slowly along the route of the wandering passages.

  ‘The Inner Styx is the river at the foot of the Devil’s Staircase. You’ll have heard it from the show cave. Downstream is a sump - a section that’s full of water right up to the roof. The only way past that is by diving. But the other way, through Five Arches, you’ve got an ascending passage and a short crawl to the Mucky Ducks. The ducks are stoops in deep water. Normally, there’s just enough air space, provided you keep your head down.’

  ‘And there’s still a long way to go.’

  ‘Yes. There’s a boulder passage, and about a hundred and fifty metres from Mucky Ducks you find a tube up in the right-hand wall. That’s another crawl you do partly full length, with an awkward bend almost blocked by another sump. Above that is a narrow eyehole that it’s just possible to wriggle through, and then you go up a mud slope, wade through a pool and locate a small fissure in the scree. And that’s it. That’s where Neil Moss died.’

  Cooper sat back, feeling exhausted and stunned. ‘It sounds like a week’s journey to me. Even if you could face all those crawls and ducks.’

  ‘Experienced cavers do it regularly. And there’s another ten miles or so of the system beyond that.’

  ‘What happens if there’s an emergency down there - if somebody is trapped or injured?’

  ‘At least one member of the party comes out and phones 999. Then the operations room at Ripley and Cave Rescue send a team out. Of course, you’re supposed to let someone know where you’re going and what time you expect to be

  283

  1

  back, so the alarm can be raised if you’re overdue. Some people don’t bother doing that. A lot of our callouts are false alarms - cavers who get lost or stop to rest, so they take longer than they expected.’